AF Monogram
Search
Media

Victory on Appeal: Second Department Affirms Directed Verdict in Insurance Defense Case

Home > Media > News > Victory on Appeal: Second Department Affirms Directed Verdict in Insurance Defense Case

Effective Advocacy Leads to the Affirmation of Key Rulings on Witness Testimonies and Judgments

 

Case Information:

Sarah Smith v. Muhammad Usman, et al
2023 WL 4611333
Decision Date:
July 19, 2023

 

Court:
Second Department, Appellate Division

Attorneys Working on Matter/Case:
Melanie Wiener, on behalf of Defendant Muhammad Usman as trial attorney in underlying matter

 

Practice Area:
Insurance Defense/Commercial Litigation

 

Case Description

The plaintiff commenced this action seeking to recover damages for injuries she allegedly sustained in a motor vehicle collision. Based on defendant’s objection, the trial court precluded the plaintiff from calling two nonparty witnesses because they were not available to testify that day and were not disclosed as witnesses during discovery. At the close of the plaintiff’s case on the issue of liability, defendant Muhammad Usman made an application pursuant to CPLR 4401 for judgment as a matter of law dismissing the complaint insofar as asserted against each of them. The court granted the applications and thereafter entered a judgment in favor of Usman and co-defendant and against the plaintiff dismissing the complaint insofar as asserted against those defendants. The plaintiff appealed and the Appellate Division affirmed. Contrary to the plaintiff’s contention, the Supreme Court providently exercised its discretion in precluding the plaintiff from calling nonparty witnesses whom she had previously failed to identify as witnesses during the discovery process and who were unavailable to testify on the day of the trial.

Contact Us

Local Respect,
State-Wide Reach

For further information about our experience, please contact our law firm on Long Island at 516-328-2300, in Brooklyn at 718-215-5300, White Plains at 914-607-7010, Rochester at 585-218-9999 or Albany at 518-535-9477 to schedule an initial consultation.